Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Firoz.T.Totanawala The Bangalore Metro Reporter ROTI MEHNGI AND THE MOBILE SASTA





























































FIROZ.T.TOTANAWALA

THE BANGALORE METRO REPORTER 

 ROTI MEHNGI AND THE MOBILE SASTA 

 The food has become expensive and gone beyond the reach of the common man, whereas, the electronic communication and entertainment equipment commonly known as the 'gizmos', more particularly, the mobile or cell phones are selling cheaper at the throw away prices. Since childhood we have been bombarded with and made to hear by our elders the watch-words such as 'Roti, Kapda aur Makaan' the 3 essential elements for our survival, not having these would render the life meaningless. 

The cheaper 'gizmos' 

The successive governments and the power horses air their promises to deliver the essential 3 elements before the gullible poor people prior to their contesting the elections and secure their confidence on that basis, and once having secured their valuable votes, the politicians conveniently fail to remember the promised assurances to be delivered to them. This is what's been happening since the day our country had secured the independence. The governments chose to remain ignorant about the basic needs of the poor people of our country. None of the past or present governments has done anything worthwhile in making the 3 essential requirements available to the common man, whereas by making available the 'gizmos' like the cell (mobile) phone, electronic gadgets, cable TV set-top box, etc. at a much lower prices the governments have set a new standard of living among the people. 

 The expensive food items 

 People who are in the lowest or even the middle income strata cannot afford to buy the vegetables like potato, onion, brinjal, lady finger and varieties of greens such as the spinach or even the drum-sticks, because they are sold at sky-rocketing rates ranging from Rs. 15/- (minimum) to Rs. 30/- per kg. The common man's stable food the rice is being sold at over R. 35/- per kg and the prices of the pulses such as the Toor Dal, Urd al, etc. have gone beyond the common man's accessible limit. All these items have become a part of rich-man's palate now. 

 The dwindling pulse-rate Whereas, the pulse-rate charged for a minute's talk over the cell phone has dwindled to its lowest to 29 paise from Rs. 17/- which was charged initially when the concept of mobile phoning and the cell phones were introduced and now a certain service provider instead of charging the end-user claims to offer incentives in return if one uses his services, and the offers such of these, no doubt, are irresistible. 

When the pulse-rate of Rs. 17/- was charged, the essential stable food item - the rice was sold at Rs. 7/- per kg and now the rice is sold at above Rs. 35/- a kg, whereas the pulse-rate charged is almost nil and the pulses/grains are sold at exorbitant prices and have entered into the items classified as luxury. 

 The farce-sightedness 

 Compliments to the farsightedness of the industrial giant the Mukesh Ambani Group, which was instrumental in bringing the revolutionary change into the lives of the common men. The group had made the use of cell phones a necessity and had connected almost all the remote villages of India enabling to communicate with each other a tremendous fete indeed! 

 The Ambani Group is also into the business of procuring the farm produce, pulses, grains and the rice as well. The Group has its own swanky air-conditioned outlets, which sell these items necessary for the public. It's a fact that the items sold thereat are meant for the people from the higher income group and definitely not for the people those are from either middle or lower income strata. The Group had never indulged in selling the food items at a price, which is affordable by the poorest of poor much against to the way the Group had carved a niche into its communication business. Of course, the Group cannot be blamed alone for this situation. 

 The theory of 'demand and supply'

 India basically is an agricultural nation and necessary schemes should have been drawn and implemented by the successive governments towards improving the agricultural outputs relative to the annual population growth. The ever sky-rocketing prices of the consumables food items indicate that nothing sort of effective schemes were drawn or implemented in the past. The government remains as a mute spectator expressing its inability to control the prices. It's apparent that the food items are in short supply and therefore tend to demand the higher prices. 

 New watch-words 

 Finally, one thing is clear that the government or the politicians who run the government cannot ever fulfill the promises made to the people, that is, offering the most sought after the 3 essential elements the Roti, Kapda aur Makaan, but they may replace the watch-words to the 'mobile, computer and TV' instead in the coming days.

Firoz.T.Totanawala The Bangalore Metro Reporter Global Investors Meet : Mining Monopoly ...

















FIROZ,T,TOTANAWALA

THE BANGALORE METRO REPORTER 

 Global Investors Meet : 



 Mining Monopoly ... 

 The Global Investors Meet saw Big Industrialists Corporate houses etc. signing MoU with the state government for establishing their projects worth lakhs of crores! MoUs were signed for various projects. Everything is OK. If the promised investments really materialise, the state would become a heaven on earth. With unemployment becoming a thing of past on these projects provide employment to about 10 lakhs, Karnataka will become a paradise on earth. But the question is - whether the promised proposed money will become a reality? Interestingly the Steel Plants and Mining industry has attracted projects worth more than two lakh with the Mining Lords and Ministers, that is Bellary Reddy Brothers prepared to invest 36000 crores! 

 The two day Global Investors Meet Organised by the Karnataka Government is definitely a success going by the hundreds of MoUs signed with the who is who of Indian Industry and Corporate houses. Except the Ambani Brothers, most of the Industries Czars have come to the GIM. As per the statistics ruled out by the government, MoUs were signed for various projects worth more than 4 lakh crores! In commonman’s language, the state will be getting investments worth lakhs of crores for various projects, which generate huge employment potential and revenue to the state. 

Well on the face of it, the GIM was a grand success and the BJP government can take extra mile publicity for this great feat, atleast for another three months. The government had spent crores of rupees towards the publicity to the GIM. Apart from the publicity department, every government departments and statutory bodies were made to spend huge money for larger than life advertisement in the newspapers and TV channels. Advertisements were inserted in newspapers of other states too including some abroad. Even prior to the GIM, Chief Minister B.S.Yeddyurappa accompanied by bureaucrats and few ministers toured many big cities to hold ‘Road shows’ in Star Hotels to attract the industrial houses etc. 

Now that the GIM has ended with MoUs being signed for projects worth lakhs of crores, the time has come to take stock of the situation and the ground realities about the projects, its impact and the result. If even 50% of the MoUs becomes a reality, the state will become semi heaven. But the government is confident of 60% fruitification of MoUs. 

On the face of it, the GIM has been monopolised by the Steel and Mining Lobby. The Steel giants have inked MoUs worth almost 2 lakh crores with Mining Lord and Minister Janardhana Reddy inking (through his wife) a 36000 crore for Brahmini Steel in Bellary region. The Steel giant Arcelor Mittal too signed a MoU for Steel Plant Project worth 30 thousand crores. In all Seven Companies have entered a MoU for Steel Plant. In a way, the Steel lobby has overhadowed all others in the GIM. 

Interestingly, all the steel companies want their own captive mining area for their steel plant. Luxmi Mittal, the No.1 in Steel business in the world, left no one in doubt that his project depends on the availability of mining area. It may be recalled that Mittal had tried his hands in mineral rich Jharkhand and Orissa. But he could not progress further because of the difficulty in getting clearances. For the last one year, Mittal was counting Karnataka for a captive mining area to establish his steel plant. And he has zeroed on Bellary region where the mining lobby is running the state government. Mittal wants captive mining area, assured water and power supply to start the project. The same is the case with other companies who are also demanding the same facilities. 

The attraction of the Mining lobby to Karnataka is understandable. The state is run by the Mining Lords who are controlling both the party and the BJP. The Mining Lord and Minister Janardhana Reddy is the Minister for Infrastructure and Tourism. His brother Karunakara Reddy is the Revenue Minister. And their hold over the government is complete as the Chief Minister B.S.Yeddyurappa had surrendered before them long back. 

Nobody expected Janardhana Reddy to sign MoU for a steel plant worth 36000 in the GIM. He is busy in establishing Brahmini Steel, a 30 thousand crore project in AP and had laid a separate railway line to transport iron ore from Bellary. The project is facing many hurdles including the hostile AP government and a CBI probe. 

With his MoU for another Brahmani Steel in Karnataka (in Bellary region) at a cost of 36000 crores, Janardhana Reddy has shocked everybody. He had proved richer than Mittal’s Arcelor, JOSCO, PSW, Vijayanagar Steels et al. Whether the Reddy Brothers have the where withal to pour 36000 crores or not, is another matter. But the fact remains that this is a very calculated move by the Mining lobby. 

As the government has signed the MoU, it is duty bound to provide captive Mining areas to the companies along with assured water and power supply. The government has created a land bank of about one lakh acres in various parts of the state and will be acquiring more very soon. It had to provide mining lands to the steel companies. The steel companies have concentrated Bellary region for their steel plant and mining. Today it is next to possible to get mining lands and commence mining. The Mining lobby have already exhausted prime mining areas in Bellary region that is Sandur, Hospet, Bellary et al. They have encroahced into forest and government lands. In normal times, they have to approach the government for mining lease and that means spending crores of rupees towards cultivating politicians in power and the bureacrats and the process is time consuming. But if they sign MoU with the government in the GIM, they will be spared a lot of money and time. And that is what exactly happened. 

 Mittal was planning to establish a steel plant in Karnataka for the last one year. He would have approached the government for lands and lease in normal way. Mittal knew what that means. So, when the government invited him to attend the GIM, he happily came and inked 30 thousand crore steel plant MoU. With the Mining Lords Janardhana Reddy and Brothers running the government, it is easy for him to get the works done. At the same time, it will be very easy for Reddy Brothers to legalise their illegal mining and get some more mining areas as they too have entered a MoU with the government. The same is the case with other Steel companies. 

 All said and done, it is not easy to take up mining in a big way to produce crores of tones steel every year. Within few years, the iron ore becomes extinct in the state. More than anything, the state can only recommend the Mining lease and it is the Central government that has to issue the same after clearance from environmental, forest and other departments. As such the final result will be ‘stand still’. But as the government itself will be moving the file, it may be possible to help the mining and steel lords. Still, it is not so easy. And the MoU may not end up with agreements. 

In the 2000 GIM held under the then CM SM Krishna, investors have promised more than one lakh crore! And over the last ten years, not even 25% of the promises have become reality. 

Be that as it may, BSY will have the satisfaction of holding the GIM and stealing the lime light attired in sparkling suits transforming from a farmer’s leader (?) to a corporate Head! And the Mining Lords monopolising the GIM is also very conspicious.

Firoz.T.Totanawala The Bangalore Metro Reporter I N D I A : The Scam Ridden Country Rs. 7,30,00,00,00,00,000 or 73-Lakh-Crores of Public Money swindled in the Scams in just 17 years


By. Firoz.T Totanawala

The Bangalore Metro Reporter


I N D I A :


The Scam Ridden Country

 

Rs. 7,30,00,00,00,00,000 or 73-Lakh-Crores of Public Money swindled in the Scams in just 17 years

 

Not long ago did our freedom fighters sacrifice their families and lives to liberate our country from the clutches of the British in order to provide us a free and an independent Nation. But the euphoria of the great Independence faded soon.  

Though we proudly proclaim ourselves as one of the largest Democracies in the world and console ourselves of having a public run Government, let us also see the other side of the coin.

After the Independence the power of running India rested in the hands of leading freedom fighters. But gradually selfish and unethical members of the society joined the race of Governing India. Soon, there were many crooks in the forefront whose priorities were their own vested interests. The so called Golden Bird- India was mauled, manhandled and manipulated by these crooks as they indulged in misappropriation of finances and their duties. India then consistently witnessed number of scams and frauds that involved amount to the tunes of lakhs of crores. Our vote seekers who come to power are indeed liable for all their actions and also accountable for financial undertakings. It is our duty and right to know about their activities after coming to power. Nevertheless, do not expect much, and hold your breath, because the details given below will surely sweep you off your feet.

In order to give citizens an insight into how much of public money is being blown up by our vote seekers we are presenting here under a brief of scams that were made public and that too only from the years 1992 to 2009.  Please note that these are the scams that were made public and the amount of the scam as officially disclosed by the respective agencies.

 

   1992 Harshad Mehta securities scam 

Rs 5,000 cr


1994 Sugar import scam   

                                                   Rs 650 cr

1995 Preferential allotment scam

Rs 5,000 cr

 

 Yugoslav Dinar scam 

Rs 400 cr

 

Meghalaya Forest scam

Rs 300 cr


1996 Fertiliser import scam

Rs 1,300 cr

 

Urea scam

Rs 133 cr

 

Bihar fodder scam

Rs 950 cr

 

1997 Sukh Ram telecom scam

Rs 1,500 cr

 

SNC Lavalin power project scam

Rs 374 cr

 

 Bihar land scandal 

Rs 400 cr

 

C.R. Bhansali stock scam 

Rs 1,200 cr

 

1998  Teak plantation swindles 

Rs 8,000 cr

 

2001 UTI scam

Rs 4,800 cr

 

Dinesh Dalmia stock scam 

Rs 595 cr

 

Ketan Parekh securities scam 

Rs 1,250 cr

 

2002  Sanjay Agarwal Home Trade scam 

Rs 600 cr

 

2003  Telgi stamp paper scam 

Rs 172 cr

 

2005 IPO-Demat scam 

Rs 146 cr

 

Bihar flood relief scam 

Rs 17 cr

 

Scorpene submarine scam

Rs 18,978 cr

 

2006 Punjab's City

1994 Sugar import scam 

Rs 650 cr

 

1995 Preferential allotment scam

Rs 5,000 cr

 

 Yugoslav Dinar Centre project scam

Rs 1,500 cr,

 

Taj Corridor scam

Rs 175 cr

 

2008   Pune billionaire Hassan Ali Khan tax default

Rs 50,000 cr

 

The Satyam scam

Rs 10,000 cr

 

 Army ration pilferage scam

Rs 5,000 cr

 

 The 2-G spectrum swindles 

Rs 60,000 cr

 

State Bank of Saurashtra scam

Rs 95 cr

 

Illegal money in Swiss banks, as estimated in 2008

Rs 71,00,000 cr

 

2009 The Jharkhand medical equipment scam

Rs 130 cr

 

Rice export scam 

Rs 2,500 cr

 

Orissa mine scam

Rs 7,000 cr

 

Madhu Koda mining scam 

Rs 4,000 cr"

 

 

CUMULATED SCAM AMOUNT is astronomical

 

Rs.73-Lakh-Crore!

 

The word 'Scam', which is impregnated with the acts like misappropriation, swindling and cheating of public money and funds, amounts to a whopping 73 lakh crores that too only for 17 years from the year 1992 to 2009, considering only the scams that were made public.

The cumulated sums of the above said money     exceeds the astronomical figure of Rs. 7,30,00,00,00,00,000 or 73 Lakh Crores since the year 1992 just in a 17 year period.

Monday, June 7, 2010

Firoz.T.Totanawala The Bangalore Metro Reporter NITHYANANDA AND HALAPPA- DIFFERENT STROKES FOR DIFFERENT PLAYERS..
































































































































FIROZ.T.TOTANAWALA

THE BANGALORE METRO REPORTER 

NITHYANANDA AND HALAPPA 

DIFFERENT STROKES FOR DIFFERENT PLAYERS… 


 All are equal before Law - they say. But in reality, some are more equal. The case in the point is the kid glove treatment being meted out to former minister Halappa and the ‘rude’ treatment to Nithyananda. While Nithyananda is doing penance in the Jail, Halappa is getting VIP treatment in Victoria Hospital and interestingly both are in Judicial custody for their amorous adventures. While Halappa is accused of raping his friend’s wife, who had given a complaint in this regard, the police are making all out efforts to make the devotees of Nithyananda to file a complaint against him. In one case the entire state machinery including the CM are behind the culprit, and the same is pitted against another . .

Political power is such a wonderful tool to do any damn thing and digest the same. Political power bends the rules of the game and even the law of the land. People with no power, let alone political, will always be at the mercy of the authority. The best example for this is Haratal Halappa, Minister who resigned in the face of allegations of rape on his friends wife. Technically Halappa is in judicial custody. But he had not seen the inside of the jail where he was supposed to be lodged. 

The moment he was remanded to JC, Halappa suddenly developed assortment of ailments and got admitted in the Meggon Hospital in Shimoga. Halappa had moved the bail application and it was rejected. He had applied for bail in the High Court. The doctors in Shimoga Hospital have decided to shift him to Bangalore’s Victoria Hospital as they said that Shimoga Hospital does not have facilities to treat Halappa’s ailments. Shimoga’s Meggon Hospital is one of the best. As Halappa suffered from ‘political’ ailments, there was not much the doctors could do. So, they shifted him to Bangalore and Halappa is ‘housed’, not lodged, in a VIP ward. He will continue to be in the VIP ward till he gets bail from the High Court. Halappa’s VIP ward is being visited by the politicians in power. The Victoria Hospital authorities are reeling out details of so called serious ailments suffered by Halappa. And the same Halappa before the episode, was a symbol of youthfulness, energy, dynamism etc. Nobody would have even dreamt that Halappa was a serious patient suffering from alteast a dozen ailments! 

 Just compare this with the case of Nithyananda alias Swamy Nithyananda. Nithyananda who ran a billion dollar spiritual institution both in India and abroad was exposed of his amorous adventures with women, by his driver who released the CD of his amorous adventures with a Tamil cine actress Ranjita. The police went in for a massive hunt for Nithyananda even though he had made it clear that he will come to Bangalore to meet the police. But the police went to Himachal Pradesh and arrested him. He was taken to Jayadeva Hospital when he complained of chest pain immediately after he was remanded to Judicial custody. Within a hour, he was sent to the Ramanagaram jail and is lodged since then. Nithyananda moved for bail but was rejected. His bail application is in the High Court. 

Despite the tell tale evidences in the CD, none has come forward to lodge a complaint against him. Even Ranjitha who was seen with Nithyananda in compromising position in force people to lodge complaint the Swamy. The police are opposing the bail plea on one or the other pretexts. Recently the bail plea was adjourned as the police have submitted that they are expecting complaints against the Swamy in few days. 

Even to this day, not a single victim (?) has come forward to lodge a complaint or despose against Nithyananda. The CID the CD, had not given any complaint, let alone evidence. The police are moving hell and earth to force people to lodge complaint the Swamy. The police are opposing the bail plea on one or the other pretexts. Recently the bail plea was adjourned as the police have submitted that they are expecting complaints against the Swamy in few days. Even to this day, not a single victim (?) has come forward to lodge a complaint or despose against Nithyananda. The CID police even have snatched the Rudrakshi Mala wore by on the pretext that he may commit suicide with the mala! 

 Nithyananda is spending his time in the cell of Ramanagaram jail and the only VIP treatment he is getting is the food from his ashram. The police have also freezed the accounts of the ashram making it difficult to his disciples to run the ashram. He is being treated as an ordinary criminal. 

 In case of Halappa, there is a specific complaint of rape and threat by the victim. In the case of Nithyananda, there is no complaint by any one including the victims (?) And while Halappa accused of rape and threat is enjoying VIP treatment and had not stepped into the jail, Nithyananda against whom not a single complaint has been filed, is cooling his heels in a solitary and that too, women’s cell in a Jail. 

Can there be a better double standard than this? It is time, the law should be applied equally to one and all to uphold the importance of law being supreme!

Firoz.T.Totanawala The Bangalore Metro Reporter JEWELLERY MARKET FRAUD- THE INSIDE STORY OF JEWELLERY FRAUD IT IS TIME CONSUMER ACTIVISTS TAKE SOME PROTECTIVE MEASURES TO PREVENT THE CHEATING OF THE GULLIBLE PEOPLE…













































































































FIROZ.T.TOTANAWALA

THE BANGALORE METRO REPORTER 

JEWELLERY MARKET FRAUD 

 THE INSIDE STORY OF JEWELLERY FRAUD IT IS TIME CONSUMER ACTIVISTS TAKE SOME PROTECTIVE MEASURES TO PREVENT THE CHEATING OF THE GULLIBLE PEOPLE… 

Yet another event has gone by in the name of Akshaya Tritiya, which was celebrated all over the country with much needed sprit and enthusiasm. And it's the auspicious time for buying the Gold. Buying Gold and Silver in various shapes and sizes especially on this occasion brings prosperity and multiplies the already acquired wealth by many folds such is the belief. People rush to the already prospered jewellery seller and make a beeline to purchase the ornaments made of Gold and Silver, and making him further prosper in his wealth and trade, irrespective of whether the purchaser prospers from the deal or not. The lucrative offers how much true? 

On a glance of any daily, one would come across innumerable number of advertisements in various colourful dimensions carrying messages pertaining to the credentials of the jewellery trader, about the types of the articles, ornaments and wares he sells and the rates at which all these wares are sold. One always claims to be more sincere, established, service oriented and sells his wares for minimal or no profit, and yet grows by many folds and achieves growth in his trade. How would this be possible? 

A leading exporter and importer of the bullion has been inserting pages of advertisements announcing his entry into the retail business. He claims that buying the jewellery from him would result in saving from 10 to 20 per cent, when compared to the purchases made elsewhere. The advertisements claim that he intends to sell the gold at the 'real rate per Gram' and this offer is done for the first time in the world. His claims of this kind could be interpreted as to the jewellery sold by other traders is at the unreal and inflated rates or the rates which include the hidden costs, which means that the purchasers were fooled by the traders all these years and the jewellery, which is in their possession, is either not real or not worth the market value. 

The annual quantum of import of Gold exceeds over 800 tonnes and the amount of Gold traded in one year exceeds double the quantity of import. A quantum of about 200-300 tonnes of Gold is sold during the festivals such as Akshaya Tritiya, Diwali, etc. The rate of 22ct of Gold sold locally varies on a day-to-day basis, which again is based on the rate of Gold traded in the international market. While the current quoted rate of Gold (22ct) is above Rs.1700 per gram, the traders vying with each other publish their selling rate, which is always lesser than the one quoted officially. 

The trade secret 

Irrespective of the quoted current rate of the Gold, the traders always announce their offers discounting from Rs. 50 to 100 per gram. For example, if the quoted current rate is Rs. 1700 per gram of Gold, then the selling rate is anything between Rs. 1550 and Rs.1650, and some claim that the discounted rate is applicable on the rates sold at Chennai, Mumbai, etc., Is practically possible to sell a commodity at a rate much lesser than its prevailing market rate of availability? Going by the principles of trading it is definitely not possible to offer a commodity at a rate much lesser than what it costs. But the Gold is an exception, because it's always sold at such a discounted rate. If that's the case, then how do the traders flourish year after year and survive to cater to the needs of their customers? Because, there's always a catch embedded into their sale. 

Firstly, the pure form of Gold, which is never purer at 100 per cent is always referred to as 99.999 per cent pure, which is fragile at its purest form and therefore is not fit and suitable for making jewellery and ornaments that are worn. Blending the purest form of Gold (24ct) with other metals such as pure copper needs to be done in order to strengthen and making it suitable for jewellery. This is where the traders play their role more cleverly, cunningly and efficiently, because no ordinary man would understand from the very look of the Gold and make out about the percentage of copper that went into its blending. A slightest increase in the percentage of copper would tend to bring down the quantum of Gold content and thus the price of the blended Gold thereto. 

The purest form Gold is equivalent to 24 carats or 100 per cent an imaginary figure and therefore each carat is equivalent to 4.1666 per cent, multiplying this figure by 22ct we get 91.667 or 91.67. It's therefore the 22ct is termed as 91.6 or 916. Similarly, 18ct is equivalent to 75 and 14ct is 58.3. Jewellery made of 18ct is much sought after ones and is consumed more in the western countries, whereas, we, the Indians prefer ornaments made of 22ct and more. 

The components such as wastages incurred in the process of making jewellery, which varies depending upon the designs made - from simple to the sophisticated ones hand or machine made, use of metals for bonding, such as Zinc-Oxide or KDM constitute more in determining the final price structure of the product than the actual rate of Gold, and this is where the traders make their killing in the profit. The final rate offered by the customers, in every transaction carried out, would invariably exceed and camouflage the discounted rates announced and offered by the traders. 

The cost of the bonding metals that go into the augmentation of weight of the final product is negligible. The metal KDM costs nothing more than Rs. 1000 per kg and the traders claim to have incurred wastages ranging from 8 to 14 per cent of the weight of the final product, thereby gaining the profit ranging from Rs. 136 to Rs. 238, when the market rate of the Gold is at Rs. 1700 per gram. Imagine the amount gained by the businessman in case an ornament weighing a just 10 grams was traded, which would be not less than Rs. 2000 to the minimum, whereas his declared discount is in the range of Rs. 500-750 per 10 gram of Gold. 

Common man - the looser 

In general, the components of the price structure would be comparatively less when the price of Gold is on its high and more when it's less, that is, it remains always in versely proportionate to the rate of the Gold. It's how the traders collect the actual market rate of the Gold from the customers, without their knowledge and it's a fact that the customers always end up paying much more than the quoted and prevailing rate of Gold to the trader at the end of every transaction. 

Only time will tell us as to whether the new entrant, who has thrown himself into the retail market trading ring as a competitor to the already established traditional jewellers, would adhere and remain committed to his true offers announced in the media forever. If he does it then, his genuine intention of offering the jewellery at the 'real rate per Gram' would not only benefit the common man, but also create a new saga of dimension in the 'jewellery business' and redefine the chemistry of Gold held by every household in India, leading the purchaser to get the 'real value for money'.

Sunday, June 6, 2010

Firoz.T.Totanawala The Bangalore Metro Reporter UNDER WATER SCAM- FISHY DEALS IN FISHERIES DEPARTMENT











































































































































FIROZ.T.TOTANAWALA      

THE BANGALORE METRO REPORTER


UNDER WATER SCAM-  

FISHY DEALS IN FISHERIES DEPARTMENT

 The Fisheries Department issues fishing contract to an influential man for continuous five years without calling for a single tender. 

Many ambitious projects of the Government towards rehabilitation of displaced tribal in Forests have not borne fruit because of the bureaucrats and unscrupulous contractors reaping the benefits. One such scheme by the National Fisheries Development Board, program for Girijans in HD Kote, stands as a shining example for this phenomenon. In the guise of Public-Private Partnership, the Nugu Reservoir's fishing rights have been leased out to an influential person from Mysore. The contract was terminated mid way and the contractor was made a partner of the Nugu Reservoir Development Committee. Besides, this so called 'partner' has been given fishing contract for five years for a nominal rate by the Director of Fisheries, without allowing anybody else to bid for the same. The contractor, now the partner in NRDC, has become a lessee of the Nugu Reservoir. And since 2001, he has monopolized the fishing contract in Nugu Reservoir. 

The Nugu Reservoir a backwater area in Heggada Devana Kote is located amidst forests habitated by girijans particularly Jenu Kurubas, who, since generations have depended on the forests for their livelihood. With the Forest laws getting more vicious these fishermen inhabitants were forced to make a living by doing labour. 

The government under its various schemes trained many unemployed tribal youths in fishing to better their living conditions. These tribal youths after obtaining intensive training could have prospered in the fishing profession, but, the Nugu Reservoir Development Committee set up by the government changed the entire scene. The Nugu Reservoir Development Committee was established by the Fisheries Development Board and financed by the National Fisheries Development Board for the purpose of rearing many species of the fishes. 

 Interestingly, the department, in stead of encouraging the local fishermen, gave the contract for rearing the fishes in the Nugu Reservoir to a private contractor by name Mr. Jagadish Gowda from Mysore. He was given the contract of rearing the fishes for three years and later renewed up to 2007-08. Though he is not a fisherman, he managed to get the contract and sadly did not allow any tribal men to enter the Nugu area. He carried out fishing with people brought from outside and cared a damn for the tribal. 

While he made millions rearing the fishes, the tribal were forced to seek alternative means for living. 

The tribal also tried to assert their rights, but in vain. They organized themselves and petitioned the Government, M.P., M.L.A, but for no outcome. The contractor already had established a nexus and was sharing the millions with concerned authorities. However, the tribal continued their fight against the injustice. They successfully organized themselves to form 'Nooraleeswara Nugu Jalashaya Fisherman's Co-op Society in 2004, but the registration was blocked by the Department authorities. 

Shockingly, there was no one to help these tribal. Even the so called elite people who publicize their support for the cause of tribal did not bother to assist them. Yet, the tribal marched ahead alone. They made several petitions to the Director of Fisheries, to give them license to fishing in Nugu Reservoir and to award the contract to Nooraleswara Nugu Jalashaya Fisherman's Co-op Society. Their last petition was on 17th November, 2007, when the state was under the President's rule. 

Now the contractor and the officials realized that they had to work out a plan to protect their interests and they did strike a novel idea. Mr. Jagadish Gowda was asked to handover the contract rights and thereafter his contract was terminated. Then, under Private-Public Partnership, Jagadish Gowda was made a partner in the NRDC. While, his fishing contract was terminated with effect from 18/12/2007, Jagadish Gowda became a partner in NRDC along with the Fisheries Department. 

 THE SHARK DIRECTOR! 

This entire episode was scripted by the Director of Fisheries who sent a proposal to the government on 20-11-2007, (3 days after the last petition by the Fisherman's Society) making out a strong case for making Jagadish Gowda, a partner under PPP for the NRDC. He eulogized Jagadish Gowda, and made a special mention of his contribution to the development of fisheries in NR. 

While the centrally sponsored scheme under PPP implies the Fisheries Department partnering with Individuals /Associations, the Fisherman's society was best suited for this partnership. It consists of local tribal whose occupation was fishing. Moreover, the government itself had given intensive training to many local fishermen and the NFDB scheme would have become fruitful. 

But, the top brass in the Fisheries department had no interest in these silly matters. The schemes meant for tribal, Adivasis etc are dry areas for them except some 'Tips' by the beneficiaries now and then. So, the government issued an order on 18-12-2007 accepting the proposal of the Director. It terminated the Fishing contract of Jagadish Gowda with immediate effect and made Jagadish Gowda a partner in the NRDC. Further, the Director had made strong recommendation to award the future fishing contract to Mr. Jagadish Gowda and astonishingly his recommendation was to award him the contract for 5 years. The Director also proposed the lease amount as Rs. 1,06,030/- for the year 2007-08 with 5 % increase every year for the next four years. This lease amount and the 5% increase ratio was proposed by the Director on his own. He had never opted for tenders and recommended the contract to be directly given to Jagadish Gowda. Shockingly, the Government blindly accepted the Directors proposal and issued the order. Even the lease amounts proposed were exactly implemented. 

EVERYTHING FISHY! 

There are many points to ponder over the activities of the Fisheries Department. 

1) The contract of Jagadish Gowda was to expire on 30/06/2008. What was the need to terminate this contract six months before its expiry? Further, it is understood that Jagadish Gowda surrendered his contract rights only after the assurance that he will become partner in NRDC and also will be awarded the fresh fishing contracts. 

2) What was the need for the Director to praise the Contractor in his proposal? Also there was no need for him to propose that the future fishing contracts be given to the same contractor? This could have been decided by the Government. Further, why should the Director propose that the contract be awarded for continuous five years? 

3) On what basis, did the Director fix the annual lease amount and what is the logic behind the 5% increase every year? The contract eventually fetches only 20% increase at the end of five years. Why weren't the tenders called for to decide the fishing contract? Whatsoever, the Department has no provision in the Transparency Act or in the rules governing the award of tenders, to award a contract without calling for tenders, and that too, for a period of five years. 

 4) The Nugu Reservoir has about 1500 hectares area with about 1000 hectares as the utility area for fishing. However, while the contractor fishes in the entire Nugu Reserviour, the area contracted is only 707 hectares, that too at a shocking rate of only Rs. 150/- per hectare.